| Book | Page | Date | Name of Deceased | Person Baptized (Proxy) | Relationship | Comments on Deceased |
| A | 7 | Archy, Chapman | Behymer, Jonathan | Uncle | Chapman Archer, son-in-law of John Behymer, Jr | |
| A | 7 | Archy, Sophia | Behymer, Jonathan | Uncle | Daughter of John Behymer, Jr | |
| A | 9 | 1840 | Bickelshymer, John | Bickelshymer, Jonathan | Son | John, Sr |
| A | 10 | 1840 | Behymer, Enoch | Behymer, Jonathan | Brother | |
| A | 11 | 1841 | Beckelshymer, Elizabeth | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Son | 3rd wife of John, Sr, Elizabeth Rinker |
| A | 15 | 1841 | Becklehamer (G't G'd Father) | Becklehamer, Jonathan | G't G'd Son | |
| A | 15 | 1841 | Becklehamer (G't G'd Mother) | Becklehamer, Jonathan | G't G'd Son | |
| A | 18 | 1841 | Behymer (Father) | Behymer, Susan | Daughter | Susan Kinsey's father-in-law |
| A | 18 | 1841 | Behymer (G'd M) | Behymer, Susan | G'd Dau'r | Susan Kinsey's grandfather-in-law |
| A | 18 | 1841 | Behymer (G'd M) | Behymer, Jonathan | G'd Son | |
| A | 30 | Dillman, Jacob | Becklehimer, Susannah | Niece | Husband of Margaret following | |
| A | 30 | Dillman, Margaret | Becklehimer, Susannah | Niece | Margaret Lemon, sister of Susannah's mother, Juliann Lemon | |
| A | 31 | Dillman, Daniel | Behymer, Susannah | Cousin | Child of Jacob Dillman and Margaret Lemon | |
| A | 31 | Dillman, Michael | Behymer, Susannah | Cousin | Child of Jacob Dillman and Margaret Lemon | |
| A | 31 | Dillman, Mary | Behymer, Susannah | Cousin | Child of Jacob Dillman and Margaret Lemon | |
| A | 42 | Epard, Margaret | Behimer, Jonathan | Uncle | Daughter of Joseph Beckelhymer and Christina Lazena, married Jacob Eppert | |
| A | 91 | Kinzey, Jacob | Bickelhamer, Susannah | Daughter | ||
| A | 91 | Kinsey, Henry | Behimer, Susannah | Niece | ||
| A | 92 | Kinsey, John | Becklehimer, Susannah | Niece | Died circa 1788, Botetourt Co, VA | |
| A | 92 | Kinsey, John | Becklehimer, Susannah | Cousin | Probable son of previous John Kinsey | |
| A | 92 | Kinzey (G'd F) | Becklehimer, Susannah | G'd Dau'r | Immigrant, John Kinsey, from Switzerland who died circa 1761, Alsace Twp, Berks Co, PA | |
| A | 93 | Kinsey, Eve | Behymer, Susan | Niece | Eve Wampler, wife of Henry Kinsey | |
| A | 94 | Kinzey, Rebecca | Behymer, Susanna | Aunt | ? | |
| A | 96 | Kinsey (G'd M) | Behymer, Susannah | G'd Dau'r | Wife of immigrant, John Kinsey | |
| A | 96 | Kinsey (G't G'd F) | Behimer, Susanna | G't G'd Dau'r | Immigrant, Christian Kinsey, from Switzerland who died Nov 1774, Alsace Twp, Berks Co, PA | |
| A | 96 | Kinsey (G't G'd M) | Behimer, Susanna | G't G'd Dau'r | Sarah, wife of immigrant, Christian Kinsey | |
| A | 99 | Lemon, Elizabeth | Becklehimer, Susannah | Niece | Unmarried daughter of George and Sarah Lemon or daughter-in-law of same | |
| A | 100 | Lemon, George | Behymer, Susan | G'd Dau'r | Father of Susan's mother, Juliann Lemon | |
| A | 100 | Lemon, Sarah | Behymer, Susan | G'd Dau'r | Mother of Susan's mother, Juliann Lemon | |
| A | 118 | Lemon, David | Behimer, Susanna | Cousin | ? | |
| A | 118 | Lemons (G't G'd M) | Behimer, Susanna | G't G'd Dau'r | ||
| A | 118 | Lemons (G't G'd F) | Behimer, Susanna | G't G'd Dau'r | ||
| A | 133 | Overholts, Joseph | Behimer, Susanna | Sister-in-Law | Married Susanna's sister, Hannah Kinsey on 23 Aug 1823 in Preble Co, OH. Died Preble Co, OH 26 Oct 1839 | |
| A | 138 | Rinker (G'd M) | Becklehimer, Jonathan | G'd Son | Mother of Jonathan's mother, Elizabeth Rinker | |
| A | 138 | Rinker, John | Becklehimer, Jonathan | Cousin | Son of George Rinker. Died 1835, Union Co, IN | |
| A | 138 | Rinker, Jonathan | Becklehimer, Jonathan | Cousin | Son of George Rinker. Died 1813. | |
| A | 138 | Rinker, George | Becklehimer, Jonathan | Cousin | Son of George Rinker. Died 12 Jul 1826, Leesville, Lawrence Co, IN | |
| A | 139 | Rinker (G'd F) | Behymer, Jonathan | G'd Son | Father of Jonathan's mother, Elizabeth Rinker | |
| A | 141 | Reed, Elizabeth | Behymer, Susanna | Sister | Married Martin Reed. Living 1826 in Hamilton Co, OH | |
| A | 177 | Wimmer, Hannah | Behymer, Susannah | Cousin | Probable daughter of John Wimmer and Hannah Lemon who were married 2 Sep 1793 in Franklin Co, VA | |
| A | 178 | Wrinkle, George | Behymer, Jonathan | Nephew | ? | |
| A | 184 | Young, Andrew | Behimer, Susanna | G't Niece | ? | |
| A | 184 | Young, Eppiderly? | Behimer, Susanna | G't Niece | ? | |
| A | 189 | 1841 | Behymer, John | Behymer, Jonathan | Brother | John, Jr. Died 9 Nov 1812, Clermont County, OH |
| A | 189 | 1841 | Behymer, Abraham | Behymer, Jonathan | Brother | Probably the Abraham Picklesimer who died 11 Oct 1823 in Floyd Co, KY |
| A | 189 | 1841 | Behymer, John | Behymer, Jonathan | G'd Son | Elder John of Amwell, Hunterdon Co, NJ |
| C | 34 | Behymer, Abraham | Behymer, Jonathan | Nephew | Abraham, Sr | |
| C | 34 | Behymer, Teny | Behymer, Jonathan | Nephew | Christinah, wife of Abraham, Sr | |
| C | 34 | Behymer, Anny | Behymer, Jonathan | Br-in-Law | Nathaniel Behymer's wife. Died 5 Jul 1815, Clermont Co, OH | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Mary | Behymer, Jonathan | Br-in-Law | Daniel Behymer's 1st wife, Mary France | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Smith | Behymer, Jonathan | Uncle | ? | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Sophia | Behymer, Jonathan | Stepson | John, Sr's 1st wife, Sophia Slingluff | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Anna | Behymer, Jonathan | Stepson | John, Sr's 2nd wife | |
| C | 34 | Burgett, Henry | Behymer, Jonathan | Cousin | ? | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Joseph | Behymer, Jonathan | Brother | Husband of Christina Lazena. Died 7 Aug 1833, Henry Co, IN | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Barbara | Behymer, Jonathan | Br-in-Law | John, Jr's wife, Barbara Weddle. Died 25 Apr 1831. | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, Catharine | Behymer, Jonathan | Br-in-Law | Samuel Behymer's 1st wife, Catherine Logan. Died 2 Jul 1818, Clermont Co, OH. | |
| C | 34 | Behimer, David | Behymer, Jonathan | Cousin | Probably the David Pickelheimer who died Jul 1818 in Hamilton or Clermont Co, OH | |
| C | 34 | Burk, James | Behimer, Susanna | Sister-in-Law | Married Susannah's sister, Catherine Kinsey. Died before 4 Sep 1828. | |
| C | 61 | Chote, Nancy | Behymer, Jonathan | Friend | ||
| C | 309 | Rincker, George | Behymer, Jonathan | Nephew | Died 1835, Union Co, IN | |
| C | 309 | Rice, Huldah | Behymer, Jonathan | Cousin | ? | |
| C | 335 | Short, Nancy | Behymer, Jonathan | Uncle | Daughter of Joseph Beckelhymer and Christina Lazena, married John Short, Jr | |
| C | 335 | Snider, Peter | Behimer, Susanna | G't Niece | ? | |
| C | 335 | Snider, (G't Aunt) | Behimer, Susanna | G't Niece | ? | |
| C | 335 | Spangle, Daniel | Behimer, Susanna | G't Niece | ? | |
| C | 335 | Spangle, (G't Aunt) | Behimer, Susanna | G't Niece | ? | |
| C | 335 | Spangly (G't G'd F) | Behimer, Susanna | G't G'd Dau'r | ? | |
| C | 335 | Spangly (G't G'd M) | Behimer, Susanna | G't G'd Dau'r | ? | |
| C | 335 | Spangly, Hannah | Behimer, Susanna | Niece | ? | |
| C | 335 | Spangly, Margaret | Behimer, Susanna | Niece | ? | |
| C | 402 | Wimmer, David | Behimer, Susanna | Cousin | ? | |
| D | 7 | 27 Aug 1843 | Hough, Peggy | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Uncle | The Peggy Behymer who married Lewis Huff on 1 Jan 1818 in Clermont Co, OH |
| D | 7 | 27 Aug 1843 | Beckelshymer, Jacob | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Nephew | Jacob, Sr. Living 1821 in Hamilton Co, OH. |
| D | 7 | 27 Aug 1843 | Beckelshymer, Elizabeth | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Nephew | Wife of Jacob, Sr. Living 1821 in Hamilton Co, OH. |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Beckelshymer, Sophia | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Step Mother | John, Sr's 1st wife, Sophia Slingluff |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Beckelshymer, Anna | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Step Mother | John, Sr's 2nd wife |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Beckelshymer, Jacob | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Uncle | Jacob, Sr. Living 1821 in Hamilton Co, OH |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Lower, John | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Nephew | Evidently, Jonathan had a sister who married a Lower |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Lower, Sarah | Beckelshymer, Jonathan | Niece | Evidently, Jonathan had a sister who married a Lower |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Spangle, Margaret | Beckelshymer, Susannah | Great Aunt | ? |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Scott, Jane | Beckelshymer, Susannah | Friend | |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Lemons, Jacob | Beckelshymer, Susannah | Uncle | Son of George and Sarah Lemon, Susannah's grandparents |
| D | 78 | 20 Jul 1844 | Lemons, Catharine | Beckelshymer, Susannah | Aunt | Wife of previous Jacob |
| Note: | Vol A: | 1840 - 1841 | ||||
| Vol B: | 1841 - 1842 | |||||
| Vol C: | 11 Sep 1842 - 22 Jun 1843 | |||||
| Vol D: | 30 Jun 1843 - 9 Jan 1845 | |||||
